vendredi 1 mai 2020

Polyvalence

Sometimes lack of validation is validation. You know when you're playing Clue and you toss a hypothesis out there? Maybe you've got the Lead Pipe in your own cards, and you say, "I think it was Colonel Mustard in the Conservatory with the Lead Pipe." Maybe you even have the Conservatory. Heh heh. But the funny thing is, when you're done with your words, nothing happens.

You look up. People are just watching you, or they're idly adjusting their cards or notepads and pencils. "Anyone?" One or two shake their heads. So you repeat it: Mustard, Pipe, Conservatory. "Nope." You ask the last person. "Jason?" He shakes his head. "Got nothin." There's a vaguely concerned air.*

Nobody ever, ever, ever comes right out and says, "I don't have any of those," glances around, surmises that you must be on to something, and congratulates you. "Nice work!" Absolutely never. You have to prod and repeat yourself. At best, someone will joke that you just won. Silence is the norm here.

I call it the Clue effect.

Sometimes in life when people can't address what you say, they push back with intensity. But that's easy to spot. Their logic doesn't make sense. They just think it does in the moment. On cursory analysis, it doesn't. On thorough analysis, it also doesn't. This is just how they're reacting. Rather than admitting the value of what you've said, or its possible value, or their lack of a good reply just this second, they basically vent.

But other times it isn't like that. Other times you just never get traction with a thought. It rolls right off, repeatedly. Like rain off a nice new raincoat.

You look up. No one's got a response.

It's like Clue.

Usually this slight impasse will come up in conversation as "shutting down" someone whose view we don't like, forcing them to splutter and go silent. But that's an overly simple reading of the meaning of no reply. The Clue effect, as I call it, is the situation where you feel as if silence means you might be on to something. And it's uncomfortable for you, the person who might have "shut someone down," partly because that could be entirely misleading. In Clue, someone could be cheating or not listening or forgetting they actually do have Colonel Mustard in their hand. Whoops! And in real life, there are a million reasons for no response.

Leaping to the conclusion that no response means we're right is a quick route to delusions. At the same time, if we are repeatedly ignored when we mention something, that can be extremely indicative, perhaps of a cultural or personal blind spot, or simply an unwillingness to confront an issue honestly. Often it's about that moment: "Now's not the time."

In our minds we often think someone's opinion ain't right, and we believe we could prove it in open discussion. But if we don't have that discussion, how do we know? It's so easy to look down on someone's foolishness, brush right by; meanwhile you're the one with the greater, more troubling misconception. A classic way to do this is to point to a flaw mentally without spending too long considering whether the flaw is superficial or deep.

If you think silence speaks volumes, I have a lot to say about that:

(A little joke...) No, see, silence emphasizes what's around it, but fails to carry its own message. Paradoxically, it does still give information. How can you read a communication without a message, you might ask? Ok! Excellent question and not asked enough! When you hear the wind in the leaves, is that a message? No... unless you're schizophrenic or having a religious experience, I suppose. It's information, though. What does it tell you? Not much, but also not zero. The air outside is not still, for example. Perhaps you don't want to wear a hat.

The fashion by which this empty string of no reply (in mathematics represented as ∅) gives definite information, but very different amounts to different observers in Clue, is reminiscent of the famous Monty Hall puzzle, which used to appear on the game show Let's Make a Deal (hosted by, not so surprisingly, Monty Hall). The situation on that broadcast stage has mired and fascinated viewers and even students of math ever since. I won't go into any more detail today, but a friend pointed out the connection after reading the above, and it's well worth noticing.

-

* For those who've never played Clue, this means that as long as no one is cheating, Colonel Mustard is definitely the culprit... figuring out whodunit is 1/3 of winning. Interestingly, after the silence, everyone has info about the murder that they didn't have before. But it'll take the others some extra detective work to reach the same conclusion: the killer was definitely Colonel Mustard. So your move tells everyone something but tells you more: exactly one fact without ambiguity or wild geese. Each of your friends now has to chase three geese, metaphorically, to figure out which two are wild. Was the murder weapon the Lead Pipe that they don't know that you have in your pocket? Was the scene of the crime the Conservatory which they also don't know you have in your pocket? Nice bluff! Meanwhile you can focus on other things. Obviously no one is exactly thrilled, because they want to win themselves, and you just pulled ahead!

jeudi 30 avril 2020

It Isn't Drinking

We too often pit free-wheeling markets against big-government communism. It isn't one or the other. We don't even live in a cocktail, eg, 60% free-wheeling markets + 40% big-government communism.

It's all about particulars. Crucially, it's about why we choose these particulars rather than those particulars. The world is not a one-line drawing. Free-Wheeling Markets vs. Big-Government Communism is not what's playing out before us.

For example, a strong social safety net makes purer capitalism more achievable. It isn't one or the other, or one obstructing the other, or some ratio mixed; here we observe a counterintuitive interaction. Counterintuitive yes, but it makes perfect sense to anyone who studies games and understands the metaphor of the "magic circle."

There must be some kind of method to this madness. We cannot just rely on God to sort the globe out for us. The famed invisible hand of trade patterns is not magic. It is actually complex cause and effect, which we can trace and harness and influence.

Can? Must.

samedi 28 mars 2020

Context

There isn't much of a market for preparing for a virus that doesn't exist... until it's tearing the market apart.

Confusing a current price tag with value is myopic.

Confusing business viability with purpose is dangerous.

Some people want government to do little more than serve business.

What's forgotten is that government outlines markets. Without rules of property and exchange and institutions for policing them, there would be no marketplace. There would be a barter mixed with a brawl.

vendredi 27 décembre 2019

The Novel City

Ever since I was a kid, five years old, I've pitched my tent on the slopes and in the breezes of the same subculture. And the breeze somehow came down to me from the mountain of elders, even though they don't play games: we see computer games and video games as possibly a little bit different from each other. Whatever name you use for all this stuff, for the larger parasol, interactive media is very ancient indeed, even prehistoric. It isn't unusual to consider all those dicey games of Knucklebones before the invention of writing a prototype of interactive media. And whatever you think/feel about them, digital games are artistically and intellectually new and meaningful (to many, including yours truly), creating a central, though not always recognized or respected, aspect of modern thinking and expression.

As with "comic" versus "graphic novel," or "flick" versus "film," or "pop science" versus "published research," or "porn" versus "erotic art," or "vegging out" versus "watching a historical miniseries," or a hundred other ways we puff ideas up or make them cozy or throw subtle barbs, the words we choose give impressions about status and seriousness that have little bearing on the potentials. It certainly occurs in more fully real, human contexts. For example, we give our judgments with word selections like "lust" versus "love." After all, what is the difference between "infatuation," "obsession," "crush," or "feeling like you're in love"? Not really anything, except the context or judgment you choose to assign. And we do love judging on context. (I recommend checking out the book "Love and Limerence" by Dorothy Tennov for research on the not-quite-universal experience of being in love.)

With games, this is an especially starkly delineated phenomenon, because "game" and "play" are (for most people) more or less dictionary equivalents of "unimportant," "unserious," "unproductive," and "childish." Even worse than that, "video game" today often means "total waste of life." To be fair, I wouldn't deny that games can be intentionally cheap and exploitative. That concerns me a lot. But then so can food or work... Can those not be dangerous? Don't they require good judgment, also? Those also concern me. Just as I don't want my food to kill me, I don't want my games to kill time.

It's difficult to talk about games without full awareness of this social attitude. I don't know if you've ever noticed it, but there are certain words that most people sound awkward and self-conscious saying: "sex" and "money" are at the top of the list. You can hear something in their voice. "Game" is another one. It's loaded with connotations that you don't necessarily want to call up. This affects the way we say the word. With many people, you'll catch a tinge of embarrassment, disapproval, or both‡. Words count, tone counts, but they don't necessarily affect what you use the word for, or even say anything about it.

There is not actually, of course, any real discontinuity between computer game and video game, or for that matter between digital game and board game and sport. But in practice, "computer game" has always said to me that the work may take nature and human experience as questions. Some refer to this category as "serious games," others as "educational games" or "edutainment," or "art games," or "interactive fiction," or even "indie games," but these are all panels on the greater umbrella, which need not, after all, present itself as serious, or have an educational purpose, or look aesthetic, or include characters who develop, or be made by a small team.

Crucially, there is, I still feel, a difference in attitude between most game players and game makers, in one camp, and the few game players and makers who see games not as entertainment or business in particular, but as rebellion, as manifesto, as interstellar ship, as tool, as thought experiment, as high art, as the new speech, as tomorrow. It is easy when adopting this view to become a little aloof, haughty, pretentious. But I think computer games are also very humbling. Even those of us with the basic skills of playing them and making them must admit that the possibilities for complexity and difficulty are staggering, that we ourselves cannot fully handle this, that we are not even close.

Novels are terrific, and the imaginative absorption of a good novel and a good game are, to me, and always have been, extremely similar. It wasn't until I was a teenager that I noticed movies could be as epiphanic as books and games; it took watching some art movies carefully. But a novel is unlike games in one way. A novel, no matter how challenging, is a one-person operation, on both the reading side and the writing side. Of course, the readers will discuss amongst themselves and read reviews, and the writers will get trusted opinions and work with editors, and we can read out loud together if we want. What I'm saying is not perfectly distinct. But a game is almost never the first way, a one-person operation. A game takes a village to make and a village to play.

-

‡ Jane Austen wrote about this same social phenomenon around novels in the 19th century, and I'd love to reference that when I find it again. Plays, novels, movies, comics, music, even logic have all been seen, in their time, as dangerous, immoral wastes of potential. This may not be all bad: maybe a few enterprising souls take the challenge to prove otherwise in the best way possible. Maybe Jane Austen's stories benefitted because she didn't want to be seen as immorally wasting lives. Ah, ok, finally! It's in Northanger Abbey and has been dubbed her "Defense of the Novel." Just two lines from it, but there's more:

"And what are you reading, Miss --?"

"Oh! it is only a novel!" replies the young lady, while she lays down her book with affected indifference, or momentary shame.

mercredi 18 décembre 2019

Tug of War

Competitiveness makes you less sympathetic. When you are competitive, you are motivated by winning itself. This means that you want to believe that when you win, it is a good thing, a thing you deserve, even though winning in a competitive scenario means someone else lost or otherwise didn't win, and moreover, succeeding where another fails inherently means they must be at some sort of disadvantage. We don't like to admit these things, but they are perfectly true. We should be careful about how we fall into competitiveness. It's an important force, even a critical one. But it blinds us in a few ways. We ought to see clearly, sometimes, at least, what they are.

mardi 29 octobre 2019

Patch

As a system of coordinated action, capitalism has strengths and unstrengths. For example, take the early success of Warren Buffet, glistering icon of dedication and good business. Very young, he decided he was going to be rich. Then he followed through, learning how it's done wherever he could. By 16, he'd saved up $5,000, which in today's terms is more like $60,000. If he could do it, why can't everyone?

In a predominantly capitalist system, much of something could get in the way that isn't fair at all. What if you have an illness that's very expensive to treat? Now your growth (or "growth," if you are a skeptic) as a citizen is impeded not only by the afflictions of the disease, but also by the afflictions of poverty and missed access. If it takes money to make money, and your funds are all absorbed away by something you can't control, then losing money means you lose even more money, and with it, chances for success, and with those, your potential to contribute to society.

Surely that isn't optimal. Most of us in my generation, and perhaps a vast majority around the world, agree this is not optimal. Not optimal, you might say, but it's the fairest system we have that works. And you aren't right if you say that. It's already quite apparent that mixed economies, when set up wisely, work as well as or better than purely capitalist economies.

If imperfect capitalism works better than capitalism, then capitalism isn't the best system. If capitalism isn't the best system, it seems likely that imperfect capitalism isn't the best system, either. Where do we go from here?

Capitalism drives cooperation by competition and competition by cooperation. When the same rules apply to everyone—a tenet of free enterprise—then on one level, the system of rules is fair. Yet anyone who has played a board game knows that applying the same rules to everyone doesn't guarantee playability, balance, or even fairness itself. And everyone who has followed a high-profile court case knows that, at least in the United States of 2019, the rules do not apply equally to everyone.

How can we keep (and improve) the cooperative, competitive, resource-managing, and motivating features of capitalism without succumbing to its many catalogued ills? If the server of the state has a bug, what is that bug, and how do we fix it?

vendredi 27 septembre 2019

Which if?

We earthlings don't like uncertainty. We usually like imagination. My suggestion: rather than depend on a show of confidence, which ultimately is rather empty or illusory, to get attention and credibility where there's real uncertainty, use imagination.

Rather than say, "We just can't draw a firm conclusion based on these numbers and this proposed mechanism," you can suggest alternative explanations that could hold water for all we know. A vivid alternative can appear positive where a statement of uncertainty would appear negative, even though they are basically the same. As a culture, we ought to embrace uncertainty more as the critical spice it is. Until then, though, use imagination?!