mardi 11 février 2025

In some ways, religion can be explained by one simple thing: communication is extremely important for humans. To decipher messages, our brains are closely attuned to correspondences. When certain flavors of pattern are detected, we try to read what is being said to us. These patterns may show up - we'd then call them coincidences - when no one is speaking. Chance will produce some naturally. Our brains are still triggered, on this primordial level, to search for a message. We feel as if someone is talking to us, even watching us, when no one is there.

It's the same broad class of phenomena as deja vu: you didn't actually experience an exactly matching situation before, but that *feeling* has been triggered. Deja vu seems to happen when an *element*, some small piece, of the situation is familiar but you can't identify which one; a sense of familiarity can then infuse and even overwhelm the gestalt. Similarly, coincidences that make us wonder whether they were somehow intended can give us the conviction that they *were*. Therefore, the feeling goes, *someone* must be there to have *intended* them for us. Someone extremely highly informed and aware of everything, to be able to arrange for this special moment, this message we have received from beyond.

Imagine you're walking in the woods. You hear a sharp rustle behind you. What's more evolutionarily sensible:

1) to assume no one is there
2) to assume someone is there

If you guessed 2, I think you got the right answer. We evolved to *assume*, for safety or other important reasons, that someone is there when we experience certain categories of sensation.

We know some of these will happen at random without anyone being there. And we can posit that evolution will have given zillions of people the *feeling* that someone was there when no one was there.

We can also guess that some of those people will continue to believe their initial hunch, even when no clear evidence follows.

I often think of the wind. The wind will have been one of the phenomena *most* responsible for giving creatures - many animals before us, not just us - the *feeling* that someone was there when no one was there. It makes good evolutionary sense to be able to filter this well, but wind is highly variable and "inventive," so it'll fool *anyone* some of the time.

Now imagine you are a deer, or a monkey. You don't have the same critical thinking skills. Maybe when you hear the wind, or the sharp rustle, and you turn around, your initial feeling is that someone is there, but then when you see nothing more, you simply assume they have left and you move on with your day.

That is, you might not have particularly clear thinking about how it works. And, contrary to the usual assumptions, you, as an animal, might have rather an animistic view of nature. That is, you might well think the wind and rain and streams and light above and so on are changes possessed of a certain amount of sentience, like yours or even greater. They might self-evidently be spirits. Or gods.

I suspect a number of animals have feelings we might call religious.

Or maybe our hyperspecialization in communication enhances this phenomenon and sets us apart, gives us much more of a feeling of hiding sentiences.

I have a sympathetic view about all this. I too have such feelings, and they're interesting. And am I a perfect gauge of when there is and there is not someone there? No. I'm also limited in how much I can say for sure. My filter and everyone else's is finite. It cannot be perfect.

But that just means I could be wrong about anything and so could you.

The argument I'm making here could be extended, but I think it's sufficient to explain a lot.

mardi 10 septembre 2024

The usual view of the political spectrum is this kind of smooth dichotomy, almost a yin-yang, an emblem of balance. There's one side, there's the other side, there's a lot in the middle, and at long last there's the "horseshoe theory" connection between the two far ends, almost like a wormhole.

There are several problems with this view.

1) Politics isn't unidimensional. There are more dimensions, several very well known and influential.

2) Even if we highlight and zoom in on this conservative-liberal essence, it's probably not accurate to represent the idea as a single variable on a spectrum.

3) Depicting conservative-liberal as a spectrum implies that the ends are complementary and equally valid.

What happens when 3 fails, for example when one end of the spectrum develops an aversion to information, science, education, empathy, etc?

Now you've got two sides, still, but one of them is frequently or largely wrong. Yet there's this illusion that both have a lot to offer, even are equally valid.

I'm for equality and egalitarianism, but I'm not for telling people their delusions are real.

vendredi 23 février 2024

Color makes up so much of vision, yet it seems mnemonic. For example, this red colander from the dollar store and these red apples near it are about the same color, but the similarity is superficial. What makes the fruit skin red and the plastic red are not the same. While the redness of the apples tells me a smidge about ripeness, the redness of the colander tells me nothing of the sort; it's a decoration. The colander is red for a sensory pleasure of redness. We seem to use color to help us distinguish among items, but not, day to day, to tell us in absolute terms what they comprise.

When we go for a walk and look at things, their colors often tell us very little. If we were more scientific, the colors might help us identify some materials on a molecular level. But the daily palettes of colors in themselves do not. Objects that reflect red do not seem to share anything else with each other, in general.

When we look out into the universe, the overview is a little different. Wavelengths are our best clues to what elements and compounds our telescopes pick up. The complexity of materials we can infer far out there is lower and we rely on staples like hydrogen and water and glycine.

Around us here on Earth, colors help us (like thumbprints) to sort objects and materials, yet tell us little to nothing about their character. White may evoke purity for some, oppression for others; even for the same people and same items, these reactions may be spelled at different times. When I see blue sky and blueberries, the similarity of hue tells me nothing, so far as I can be sure. Yet I know that clear daytime skies and the light dusty patches on those berries look similar - despite, I think, having nothing in common beyond a relatively small wavelength gap.

dimanche 11 février 2024

A price tag does not accurately measure the value of anything.

Most of us accept this on some level, yet we spend lots of time living as if prices do accurately reflect value.

And some of us are deceived entirely. There are monetary fundamentalists among us.

It isn't that we shouldn't have prices or money, but given that neither actually mirrors value - does not reflect it either accurately or precisely - it is dangerous to encourage a *full* illusion otherwise. That wouldn't be like an illusion in the movie theater, where you can forget you're watching a movie, then five minutes later walk out, step into your car, and drive away, no crazier than before. When we believe money truly mirrors value, some truly horrible things happen: children starve, diseases aren't treated, people freeze sleeping on the street, etc.

lundi 1 janvier 2024

People make a big deal about not caring what anyone thinks, and then they become spiteful dolts over the silliest things. It's as if what they really want is to warn others not to care what they think, so they can opine recklessly in reaction to others. The old two-way street clogs up. Many seem, by this prosaic "not caring" heroism, to be admitting their own opinions tend toward jerks of the knee.

I care what people think, and that's in part because my thoughts are worth something; I want people to care what I think in turn, given that I care what they think.

It isn't that *I* think it, or that I *think* it, but that I have put a lot of care into the thought. That is why I think others should care, and it is why I care.

dimanche 26 novembre 2023

When there's some issue that's polarized, people tend to model this mentally in "black and white," ie, binary. That mistake drives a lot of polarization. And it usually is, in fact, a mistake.

I'd say when you're considering A or B, it would be much better to think of it as a qubit rather than a bit.

It isn't ALL A, NO B versus ALL B, NO A, usually. Not necessarily. It could be A. It could be B. It could be A and B in different amounts or at different times (or for different entities or goals). It could be neither A nor B. It could be 50% A, 1% B. It could be 100% A, 100% B. It could be 0% A, 0% B. Get it? This is how qubits work.

Even if the reality is 0% A, 100% B, it helps to understand why A might appear true, might seem like a more compelling explanation, might be easier to understand or remember. Just as we shouldn't think only in binary, it's also true that when we explain why an incorrect view is maintained by some people, we shouldn't only ascribe malicious motives, or only ascribe innocent ones.

mercredi 18 janvier 2023

When you smash particles together, sometimes you get bigger particles. In effect, this is how all the elements are formed by stars.

It doesn't seem counterintuitive to me that when you smash *enough* together, what you get is new spacetime. In other words, spacetime would be a little analogous to diamond versus charcoal - smoosh together enough under enough pressure and heat, and you get this special result - not just a new form of matter, this time, but spacetime itself.

That's what I think. Black holes synthesize spacetime, and then all that stuff that fell together bounces out into the new spacetime created, and it looks - or can look - kinda like what we see around us in the universe.

It's only one (cosmogonic) hypothesis but I've never seen one that makes more sense to me.

Bonus 1: The math of black holes says that spacetime inside the event horizon is stretched just about infinitely, so the volume inside is much larger than the volume (as seen from) outside.

Bonus 2: When scientists estimate the amount of mass-energy in the observable universe and put it into the equation for the event horizon of a black hole, they get a radius that's about as big as that of the current observable universe. (That seems a little tricky or coincidental, though, because the observable universe is expanding fast, yet its mass-energy is believed to be constant. However, maybe all is not lost for that line of argument, because while the universe is expanding, so is the observable universe - that is, over time, we will catch photons from parts of the universe we cannot yet observe. If the correspondence between estimated mass-energy within the observable universe and radius of observation were to tighten up with better data and stay consistent over time, that would seem like a strong argument.)